Product Reviews

Review: I have always wanted a black powder pistol. When I saw this 1858 Remington ss sheriff .44 I knew I had to have one and I was not disappointed. Beautiful fit and finish,, nice weight,, good looking gun. It seems to function perfectly and I am looking forward to shoot it. I have just recently received the caps,, lead balls,, and the powder so it won't be long until I try it out. Great shipping,, 👍 I am very happy with this product. Thank you EMF.

Review: Received pietta Nma sheriff after 4 day wait. Package came undamaged, and in great shape. Unpackaged revolver and was very happy with what I found. Revolver was covered in packing and shipping grease.quick wipe down and revolver looked great. After inspection was very pleased with fit, function and finish of the revolver. Haven’t fired it yet but ran three cylinders worth (24) caps without a malfunction. Really liken this stainless nma sheriff model so far. Can’t wait for the .454 round balls to come in.

Review: The best looking revolver I have. Finish is near perfect. Mechanicals are smooth, light trigger, excellent timing and lock up. Barrel/cylinder gap is tight. Drop in 45 cylinder also fits and works well even though it is a 5 shot. Negatives and nit picks, $46 shipping is way to high, gun had black soot residue on underside of frame top strap even at the rear, and inside the hammer channel. Bore was dirty for a new gun. Nipples were dirty w/flash holes partly obstructed. But, no evidence of being fired other than this. Cylinder face and chambers were clean, no turn marks. Foam inner box had damage probably due to heavy gun being banged around in shipping/handling (I have other Pietta BP with this issue). So, clean it up and remove the heavy oil coating and it is very nice overall. By far the best price I found (even with high shipping). Shipped quickly. Overall very satisfied.

Review: Better price than Taylor's the revolver is extremely accurate being fixed sights and unable to adjust cleaning is so much easier being stainless. But shipping is horrible $45-$75 shouldn't have to pay for hazmat shipping when it dose not contain black powder or lead ..steel oil wood and foam.. non hazardous materials!

Review: Great customer service, always willing to give 100% will be doing business with them again, Thanks Charlie for your help and follow up A+A+A+

Review: I purchased the gun on 11/242023 and received on 11/30/2023.This is a piece of work that Pietta should be very proud of. Thank you team EMF for your business. I'm looking forward to my next purchase as soon as its available.

Review: Very nice quality with very smooth action. Shipped quickly for a very good price. Big Thank You to EMF and Pietta!

Review: Absolutely gorgeous. I got this one because I loved the blued steel Sheriff model so much. It might just live in the presentation case forever, though. I’m one of those people, yeah. The blued steel gets all the attention for Range tests.

Review: As the owner and very active shooter of black powder revolvers I’ve pretty much learned to stick with the 1858 New Army design for my daily shooter and competitive shooting situations. With practice, loaded cylinders can be change as fast as the average shooter can change a magazine in a modern handgun. Of course the downside of shooting bp is the requirement to clean the revolver as soon as your day is done to protect from corrosive bp causing rusting issues on your beautiful antique revolver. That is where this gorgeous 1858 Remington New Army 5 1/2” Stainless Steel Sheriffs model comes in to play. With it’s perfect size barrel for quick draw and pin point shooting at 20 yards or less, man size targets accuracy at much greater distance, I’ve absolutely fallen in love with this beautiful revolver. I purchased my unit directly from here on EMF Co website and the transaction was smooth, shipped quick and I received it very fast with absolutely no complaints at all. The revolver I received had near perfect fit and finish and I am definitely planning on buying another Stainless Steel Sheriffs Model once I get my 2 gun western belt setup.

Review: When I saw Pietta made the 1858 Sheriff in stainless steel, I knew I had to have it. It just arrived and it's even nicer than I had imagined. This is a BEAUTIFUL piece! It has the same perfect weight, balance, and feel of the steel Sheriff, but it's immediately obvious that they double-down on the workmanship. The fit of everything is perfect. It locks up as well as any revolver you've ever handled. The checked grips are really a nice touch and feel wonderful. I had to pause writing this so I could go pick it up again! To me, the 1858 Sheriff is the best of all the reproductions because of its look, feel, strength, .44 caliber power, balance, length, and ingenious design. And now having all of that in stainless steel . . . oh my gosh . . . it's a magnificent piece you'll be VERY proud to own.